ban for hackers of custom maps?

[H3ndriX-pt]

I guess this has been suggested before, but why not ban maphackers of custom maps? I was gonna ask in the maphacker section, but i guess this would be the apropriate section :p

Maybe only some maps like notd, or dota and tags, and not the melee ones

[Nery]

first at all u are PT right?:D cool see a bro here:D

i only now a few pts here...

now your suggestion.

i think no. cuz cg is foru fun... except cw or real melee games like Grubby VS toD or games like this...

i hope admins think in ban mh in cw.
but in dota or other mods games i think no need.

[sakal]

Originally posted by DeadNery
first at all u are PT right?:D cool see a bro here:D

i only now a few pts here...

now your suggestion.

i think no. cuz cg is foru fun... except cw or real melee games like Grubby VS toD or games like this...

i hope admins think in ban mh in cw.
but in dota or other mods games i think no need.

Well... if hacking is fun for u... dont u think hacking destroys fun ?

[H3ndriX-pt]

well i agree with the above post, hacking destroys fun for others. Anyway, as u may or may not know, there is a quite large notd community, and we would really like to see maphackers that we report (with 100% proof) banned.

Same would apply to dota or other games if ppl feel like it should be done, but i guess im asking to ban notd maphackers.

Now, for the reasons i think they don't get ban:

1. They can always get new account and new ip, and join again for cg, while if they done that in pg they would lose all they stats. So really, it doesn't affect them much.

2. Ppl from dota and similar games reporting maphackers without any 100% evidence, giving more work to admins.

---

I think u could make it so that at least the clan chieftains can report maphackers. And maybe put a rule like "if u report more than 2ppl without proof, ur forbidden to post more".. That would solve the 2nd point :D

Anyway, if there are any other reasons why not to ban them i would like to know. tks :p

[Nery]

Originally posted by sakal
Well... if hacking is fun for u... dont u think hacking destroys fun ?

cg is for fun not hacking.

80% of dota is for fun...
20% more seriosly dota ( with ban list ) maybe in these dota mh can get ban...

[sakal]

Yes but hacking destroys fun to ppl who plays against hackers... Anyway... Since I dont know too much about banlist and NOTD I would like to ask something...

1. Is it possible to have a banlist for NOTD or it is just for DotA ?
2. Can banlist ban IP or it just bans acc ?

Suggestion :

Create forum for reporting maphackers/leavers or whatever destroys fun in game for others in CG games and find moderators for it... ppl who are reported and and have been prooved as cheaters should be added in one sticky topic in that forum so ppl who use banlists can add them to their banlist...

I am sure there are ppl who would take this job... For example elf for DotA, someone from NOTD clan for NOTD games, someone from clan fcuk for footie games etc.

Anyway... I think maphackers should be banned ( IP )where ever they played game... cg or pg...

[Elf]

Well as i remember you can;t receive ban in Dota or CG.
Yea i know its stupid -_- but as i remember you can use banlist for this ;) Banlist have IP database where its saving the name of players that logged from specific IP. But if peoples have dynamic IP this is the problem :( There was few cases in Hacks about MH in cg and anyone didnt get ban.
Well yes i agree your ideas but i think admins won't =P

[Ykc]

just ban them in cw 's couse it would be stupid to ban ppl with stats 0-0 that play dota..